Thank you for visiting Paducahsun.com, online home of The Paducah Sun.

June 2012
27 28 29 30 31 01 02

Click here to submit an event.

Judge's ouster sought after she refused to hear gay adoptions

By BRUCE SCHREINER Associated Press

LOUISVILLE -- Civil rights groups are seeking the removal of a Kentucky judge who declared his conscientious objection to handling adoption cases involving gay and lesbian adults.

The American Civil Liberties Union of Kentucky and other groups complained to the state's judicial disciplinary commission about Judge W. Mitchell Nance, who hears family court cases in Barren and Metcalfe counties, a rural stretch of south-central Kentucky.

Nance filed an order stating that attorneys should notify court officials if their adoption cases involve gay adults, so that he can take steps to recuse himself. He cited a state law requiring judges to disqualify themselves from proceedings when they have a personal bias or prejudice.

The judge said he believes as a "matter of conscience" that "under no circumstance" would it be in a child's best interest to be adopted "by a practicing homosexual." He said his "conscientious objection to the concept of adoption of a child by a practicing homosexual may constitute 'personal bias or prejudice'" that would require his recusal.

The judge then proposed a review process that his critics said would enable him to identify adoption cases involving gays and preemptively recuse himself from them. Kentucky Chief Justice John D. Minton Jr., is reviewing that proposal.

Kentucky law allows gay couples to adopt, and the U.S. Supreme Court ruling in 2015 that legalized same-sex marriage nationwide specifically cites adoptions by same-sex couples as "powerful confirmation from the law itself that gays and lesbians can create loving, supportive families."

The ruling also emphasized that people whose religious doctrines forbid condoning same-sex marriage must be given "proper protection as they seek to teach the principles that are so fulfilling and so central to their lives and faiths." But Justice Anthony Kennedy's majority opinion declared in the same paragraph that the Constitution does not permit the state to treat same-sex and opposite-sex couples unequally.

Nance's statements critical of adoptions by gay adults show he's "incapable of being fair to certain individuals because of their sexual orientation," said William Sharp, legal director for the ACLU of Kentucky. His actions violate Kentucky's code of judicial conduct by eroding public confidence in the judiciary, critics said.

"The only ethical thing for Judge Nance to do is resign the bench, but since he refuses, the necessary next step is for the Kentucky Judicial Conduct Commission to remove him," said Chris Hartman, director of the Fairness Campaign, a gay rights organization.

Nance declined comment Tuesday through a court official.

Comments made about this article - 0 Total

Comment on this article

Your comment has been submitted for approval
captcha c2039444b6b4405ca07acf4dbb1d4f3a
Top Classifieds
  • HAVANESE PUPS AKC Home Raised, Best H ... Details
  • Labrador Pups $500 839-1198 Details
  • Details
  • Beautifully &Totally Renovated Co ... Details
  • Lower town Condo w/ garage, Leslie He ... Details
  • SEEING is believing! Don't buy p ... Details
  • House for SaleAurora, KY2 Bdr, Liv RM ... Details
  • 2007 NissanAltima Hybrid147,000 miles ... Details
  • AUTOMOVER SPECIAL6 lines - 14 dayson ... Details
  • Red 2013Ford Taurus Loaded30,000 + mi ... Details
  • 32'-2015 camper, sleeps 6, too m ... Details
  • 2002 HARLEY DAVIDSON "BAD BOY&qu ... Details

Most Popular
  1. Bowyer drives Lightning McQueen
  2. For summer bass, shaky head fishing won't be a mistake
  3. CRAZY Insanely costly primary leaves nothing settled
  1. Infestation of spiders forces local couple out of their home
  2. Family picks Paducah for large 50th reunion
  3. Local woman killed in Graves crash
  1. Bowyer drives Lightning McQueen
  2. Carpenter bees
  3. For summer bass, shaky head fishing won't be a mistake

Check out these recently discussed stories and voice your opinion...